← Back to Playbook
Part 9

9.1 Marketplace Failure Protocols

CRISIS MANAGEMENT

Every marketplace faces crises. The difference between platforms that survive and those that fail is the speed and quality of the response. These protocols are mandatory — not optional.

CRISIS RULE: When a crisis is identified, it becomes the single priority. Cancel all other activities until the crisis is resolved. Speed of response is more important than perfection of response.

5 Crisis Scenarios

Crisis Trigger Severity Immediate Actions Recovery Time
Male Ratio Spike Female ratio drops below 45% Critical Pause all male onboarding immediately. Activate top 10 female connectors. Double female referral reward for 72 hours. 48–72 hours
Engagement Collapse Sparks sent drops below 0.5/user/week Critical Manually curate 5 matches for every active user. Push notification campaign. Review last 2 weeks of product changes. 1 week
WOM Engine Failure Referral rate drops below 10% High Activate all 4 WOM mechanics simultaneously. Increase referral reward by 50%. Conduct 10 user interviews to find friction. 2 weeks
High Churn D7 retention drops below 30% Critical Conduct 10 user exit interviews immediately. Identify top 3 churn reasons. Address root cause before acquiring new users. Address root cause first
Safety Incident Any reported safety concern Zero Tolerance Respond to affected user within 1 hour. Remove reported user pending investigation. Document fully. Review and update protocols. Immediate — no delay

Crisis Protocol Detail

Too Many Male Users
Trigger: Male ratio exceeds 60% for 3+ days

Immediate Actions:

  • Pause all male signup campaigns
  • Activate all female acquisition channels simultaneously
  • Increase female referral incentive by 2x
  • Brief connector network: female recruitment only this week

Root Cause: Usually caused by paid social targeting too broad, male influencer content, or viral male-skewed content. Recovery Time: 7–14 days to restore balance with aggressive female acquisition.

Low Match Activity
Trigger: Spark→Meet conversion below 10% for 7 days

Immediate Actions:

  • Manual matching: review all unmatched users and seed introductions
  • Direct user-to-user introductions via founder account
  • Send personalised match suggestions to top 20% most active users
  • Conduct 5 user interviews to identify friction

Root Cause: Usually caused by low profile quality, algorithm issues, or demographic mismatch in user base. Recovery Time: 3–7 days with manual intervention.

Event Attendance Drops
Trigger: Event attendance below 20 people or no-show rate above 40%

Immediate Actions:

  • Activate connector network for emergency invitations
  • Reduce event size to 15–20 people maximum
  • Move to a smaller, more intimate venue
  • Offer existing attendees +1 invitations

Root Cause: Usually caused by poor timing, competing events, or declining brand excitement. Recovery Time: Redesign event format. Add novelty. Change venue.

User Churn Increases
Trigger: 30-day retention drops below 40% for 2 consecutive weeks

Immediate Actions:

  • Conduct 10 user exit interviews immediately
  • Identify top 3 churn reasons
  • Activate re-engagement campaign for churned users
  • Review last 2 weeks of product changes for regression

Root Cause: Usually caused by poor match quality, low meeting conversion, or product friction. Recovery Time: Address root cause before acquiring new users. Churn kills liquidity.

Safety Incident
Trigger: Any reported safety concern from a user

Immediate Actions:

  • Respond to the affected user within 1 hour
  • Remove the reported user from the platform pending investigation
  • Document the incident fully
  • Review safety protocols and update if needed

Root Cause: Safety incidents destroy female trust and brand reputation permanently if mishandled. Recovery Time: Zero tolerance. Act immediately. Communicate transparently.