← Back to Playbook
Part 8

8.2 Scale vs Pivot Decision Tree

PMF & SCALE

PMF Decision Tree

Outcome Condition Action
SCALE All metrics met Proceed to Phase 4. Begin Singapore preparation. Raise Series A. Expand team.
EXTEND 1–2 metrics missed Extend Phase 2 by 6 weeks. Focus exclusively on failing metrics. Re-evaluate at end of extension.
PIVOT 3+ metrics missed Conduct 20 user interviews. Identify root cause. Choose: extend Phase 2, narrow to expat-only, or pivot to group social events.
EMERGENCY NPS <30 Stop all acquisition. Fix the product. Conduct 20 user interviews within 48 hours. Do not acquire new users until NPS >40.

Pivot Decision Tree — 4 Scenarios

Scenario A: Supply Shortage (CRITICAL)
Triggers: Gender imbalance (female < 45%) · Install growth stalling (< 200/week)

Step Action Owner Timeline
1 Immediately pause all male-targeted paid acquisition CEO Same day
2 Activate all female acquisition channels: yoga studios, MBA programs, expat women groups CEO + Growth 48 hours
3 Personally DM 20 female super-connectors with personalised invitations CEO 48 hours
4 Review onboarding funnel for female drop-off points Product 72 hours

Pivot Option: If female ratio does not recover to 48%+ within 2 weeks: extend Phase 1 by 4 weeks and do not launch events.

Scenario B: Engagement Collapse (HIGH)
Triggers: Match → Meeting rate < 10% · Sparks sent per user < 1/week

Step Action Owner Timeline
1 Audit match quality — are profiles complete and photos verified? CEO 24 hours
2 Manually curate 5 high-quality matches per active user CEO + Community 48 hours
3 Add in-app experience prompts: suggest 3 specific venues for first meeting Product 1 week
4 Reduce Spark cost temporarily or add bonus Sparks to active users CEO 48 hours

Pivot Option: If meeting rate does not recover to 12%+ within 3 weeks: pivot to curated group experiences as primary matching mechanism.

Scenario C: WOM Engine Failure (HIGH)
Triggers: Referral installs < 10% of total · WOM growth flat for 2+ weeks

Step Action Owner Timeline
1 Interview 10 active users: why haven't they referred anyone? CEO 48 hours
2 Increase referral reward — test double-sided incentive (both referrer and referee get bonus Sparks) CEO + Product 1 week
3 Create shareable Match Card feature: users share anonymised match story to Instagram Stories Product 2 weeks
4 Activate NPS survey for all users with 3+ meetings — identify promoters and personally ask for referrals CEO 1 week

Pivot Option: If referral rate does not reach 15%+ within 4 weeks: shift budget from paid acquisition to event production to generate organic content.

Scenario D: PMF Gate Failure (STRATEGIC)
Triggers: PMF gate metrics not met by July 2026 · Two or more red flags simultaneously

Step Action Owner Timeline
1 Do not raise funding or expand to new city — stabilise Bangkok first CEO Immediate
2 Narrow target to expat-only cohort (higher disposable income, lower cultural friction) CEO 1 week
3 Pivot event format: replace 1:1 matching events with group social dinners (lower commitment, easier to fill) CEO + Events 2 weeks
4 Extend Phase 2 by 6 weeks. Reset PMF gate to September 2026. CEO Decision within 1 week

Pivot Option: If September 2026 PMF gate also fails: consider full pivot to B2B corporate social events or sell the influencer network as a standalone product.